Sex is between our legs, gender identity is in our head: Kami Sid

Trans activist was responding to Almas Bobby's suggestion that medical tests be conducted on transgender persons


By Fawad Hasan

KARACHI: Trans rights activist Almas Bobby sparked controversy on Sunday when she called for a medical test for transgender persons before issuing them national ID cards.

“Run a medical check-up on all of us, including me, and I will accept whatever the results are,” Bobby, who is president of the Shemale Foundation Pakistan, said in a talk show hosted by actor Hamza Ali Abbasi on Bol network.

Bobby lashed out at men who were ‘pretending’ to be transgender persons and attending international conferences held abroad. “We have been stuck here all our lives, and these men go to the United States, Nepal, Sri Lanka and elsewhere as khwaja sira,” she added.

The video clip, which has been making the rounds on social media, irked many in the transgender community as they took to Facebook to rubbished Bobby’s statement.

Kami Sid, a well-known transgender model, condemned Bobby for her remarks, arguing that the recent passing of Transgender Persons (Protection of Rights) Bill 2017  in the National Assembly is a result of the hard work of transgender activists who Almas termed ‘fake’.

OPEN LETTERDear Almas Bobby Ji,With due respect, what you couldn't say on National Television let us (Transgender community of Pakistan) say that to openly to you.What you are referring as True Khawajasira's are those who have gone through castration (Commonly known as Nirban). It is true that getting castrated and further having sex reassignment surgery is a protocol adopted by international medical associates linked with Transgenders, but it is also true that a lot do not want to or cannot get operated because of various reasons. You are a senior person and we truely respect you for what you are but if you call yourself a True Khawajasira (True Transgender ) just because you have gone through an operation than kindly do not forget that once you were also a fake Transgender. Pakistan is evolving slowly when it comes to medical treatment of Transgenders. You have mentioned that so called fake Transgenders are going to Sri Lanka, Nepal etc , than you should also be knowing that a Transgender protection bill has been passed for the first time in the history of Pakistan because of these so called fake Transgender activists. Today Transgender community is becoming visible because of these so called fake Transgender people and today Transgender community is availing better medical facilities because of these so called fake Transgenders rights fighters. Please, for God sake don't confuse the world anymore. We have fought really hard up till now. If you cannot encourage us at least don't discourage us. Try to understand what the term Transgender means. It's a slow process of transitioning from once gender to another, and the speed varies from person to person circumstances. We can pray that people like you get to know real meaning of humanity and help people of their own kind. We never stopped and we will never stop. Proud to be Transgenders and proud to be what we are. With lots of love and hope,Pakistani Transgender Community & Transgender Allies(Is parcham Kay sayae talay hum aik Hain kio ki hum sab Insan hain)#Stopsterotyping #Transrightsarehumanrights #AlmasBobby #Pakistan #WeareOne #Transpower

Posted by Kami Sid on Monday, June 18, 2018

Speaking to Cutacut, Sid said, “People of the transgender community should stop thinking about what lies between the legs and focus more on self-identification. We should always remember that sex is between the legs whereas gender is in our head.”

Regarding the medical check-up requirement for ID cards, as suggested by Bobby, Sid went on to say that to examine gender, experts are required to take blood tests to find out about hormones and chromosomes and during that test “nothing happens between the legs”.

She also said self-identification is a basic human right and one should be allowed to identify him or herself without coercion. “If I am saying that I’m a girl then the world will have to accept me as a girl no matter what.”

Kami’s stance goes along the Transgender Persons Act 2018 which says that people have the right to perceive their identity on their own. “A Transgender Person shall have a right to be recognised as per his or her self-perceived gender identity, as such, in accordance with the provisions of this Act,” it reads.

Kami says if people really want a medical assessment before issuance of a ID cards then there should be examination of all those men who can’t reproduce “because what if they are also transgender persons pretending to be men”.

In August last year, the National Database and Registration Authority (NADRA) had introduced a new policy for registration of transgender persons and issuance of their NICs. The renewed policy has allowed transgender persons to mention their ‘guru’ name instead of parents’ names. Earlier, only transgender people who knew their parents could obtain the NICs.

Bindiya Rana, probably the most revered member of the transgender community in Pakistan, also posted a video on her Facebook and condemned Bobby’s comments. “Transgender persons still have to beg for alms and dance to earn bread. There should be a brain checkup for those who are calling for transgender examination because it’s a human right violation if you don’t accept someone’s gender as perceived by him/her,” she said.

Another trans rights activist, Shehzadi Rai, said it was due to misunderstanding and lack of education that people are unable to fully grasp the definition of transgender.
“The World Health Organisation says it is up to the person to decide his gender. After that, it is one’s own choice what she/he does with the body,” Shehzadi said.
“A lot of people go through the surgery but many don’t and we support their decision because we have to be united as a community. No one should look down upon a transgender person if he has not gone through a surgery for complete transformation,” she added.
Shehzadi said Almas has indirectly promoted castration among transgender people, a procedure which is illegal in Pakistan and hence often ends up a hack job.
The transgender activist termed Almas’ comment “a stunt to defame the transgender community” in the wake of the recently passed bill.

Read More